8
9

To clarify the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016, to appropriately limit the application of defenses based on the passage of time and other non-merits defenses to claims under that Act.

7/17/2025, 11:31 AM

Summary of Bill HR 4235

The bill H.R. 4235, introduced in the 119th Congress on June 27, 2025, titled "To clarify the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016, to appropriately limit the application of defenses based on the passage of time and other non-merits defenses to claims under that Act," aims to provide clarification and limitations on defenses related to time passage and non-merits defenses for claims under the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016.

Congressional Summary of HR 4235

This bill permanently extends and expands judicial authority under the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016. The law allows and establishes procedures for civil claims and causes of action to recover artwork and other property lost between 1933 and 1945 because of Nazi persecution.

Among the changes, the bill removes the deadline for filing civil claims or causes of action. Currently, the filing deadline is December 31, 2026. (Claims must still be filed within six years of the claimant's discovery of the property in question.)

The bill permits courts to exercise jurisdiction over civil claims or causes of action against a foreign state without regard to the nationality or citizenship of the alleged victim. The art or property at issue must still have a connection to the foreign state's commercial activities in the United States.

Additionally, the bill authorizes nationwide service of process, which allows courts to exercise personal jurisdiction over defendants in any judicial district where they may be found, reside, have an agent, or transact business.

Finally, the bill limits the defenses that may be asserted against civil claims or causes of action, including by prohibiting

  • defenses based on the passage of time, including equitable defenses such as laches (i.e., unreasonable delays); and
  • discretionary bases for dismissal that are unrelated to the merits of the claim, including international comity (i.e., deference to the laws of other countries).

These changes apply to pending and future civil claims or causes of action.

Current Status of Bill HR 4235

Bill HR 4235 is currently in the status of Bill Introduced since June 27, 2025. Bill HR 4235 was introduced during Congress 119 and was introduced to the House on June 27, 2025.  Bill HR 4235's most recent activity was Referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary. as of June 27, 2025

Bipartisan Support of Bill HR 4235

Total Number of Sponsors
1
Democrat Sponsors
0
Republican Sponsors
1
Unaffiliated Sponsors
0
Total Number of Cosponsors
17
Democrat Cosponsors
11
Republican Cosponsors
6
Unaffiliated Cosponsors
0

Policy Area and Potential Impact of Bill HR 4235

Primary Policy Focus

Alternate Title(s) of Bill HR 4235

To clarify the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016, to appropriately limit the application of defenses based on the passage of time and other non-merits defenses to claims under that Act.
To clarify the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016, to appropriately limit the application of defenses based on the passage of time and other non-merits defenses to claims under that Act.

Comments

Angie Franklin profile image

Angie Franklin

720

8 months ago

This bill is good, it helps people get back stolen art. It affects everyone.

Jayla Dickinson profile image

Jayla Dickinson

666

8 months ago

I can't believe some people are still trying to defend the passage of time as a reason to not return Holocaust Expropriated Art. This bill is long overdue in clarifying that excuse is not valid. It's about time we hold those accountable for their actions. This bill affects all those who have been wronged by the theft of art during the Holocaust. #JusticeForHolocaustSurvivors